The Discount You Can’t Build

The Deals We Couldn’t Ignore

We recently bid on two Class A communities in core Austin submarkets.

We lost both.

Came in second, twice.

That has been happening to us a lot lately, and there is a reason for it that we will get to.

Both properties are now under contract, so we can share the numbers without sharing the names.

The first would cost about $285,000 per unit to build today. It went under contract at roughly $210,000 per door.

The second, in a better location, carries a replacement cost we estimate at $285,000 to $300,000 per unit. It is under contract at about $215,000 per door.

Neither is a broken building. Both are recent-vintage, well-leased, institutional-quality assets.

The discount has nothing to do with quality and everything to do with the cost of building them.

That is the part that matters.

What Turns a Discount Into a Return

Here is the catch, and there is always a catch.

Buying below replacement cost is compelling, but by itself it is not enough.

Think about a house. Buy it below build cost on a street people are leaving and you have bought a cheap house on a dying street.

The discount only matters if there is a real reason for values to rise.

In Austin, we believe that reason is already taking shape. A number of data points suggest we are entering a period of meaningful rent growth.

1) Job Growth

As stated above, Austin ranked eighth in the nation for percentage job growth through May 2026. Organizations like Opportunity Austin continue to attract employers and high-paying jobs, creating the demand that ultimately fills apartments.

And the announcements keep coming.

In May, work began on the 2,600-acre Dog’s Head development after the developer disclosed it had been approached by a Fortune 100 company exploring an advanced manufacturing campus.

In June, Apollo Global Management announced plans to establish a second headquarters in Austin.

In July, Tesla leased the largest available industrial building in the market, totaling 682,000 square feet. ICU Medical and Otsuka also announced a $500 million expansion of their pharmaceutical manufacturing facility.

Together, these announcements reinforce the same story: Austin continues to attract jobs, investment, and the long-term demand that fills apartments.

2) High Absorption

Preliminary Q2 2026 data suggests Austin may have just had one of the strongest leasing quarters in its history.

If the preliminary numbers hold, Austin absorbed roughly 8,000 units during the quarter, pushing market-wide occupancy from approximately 88% to 90%. About 30% of Austin submarkets are now at 92% occupancy or higher.

Excess supply is being absorbed much faster than many expected.

3) Decreasing New Supply

The construction pipeline continues to shrink.

Preliminary data shows new deliveries fell ~12% in Q2, from 3,390 units to 2,971 units.

For comparison, Austin delivered 7,972 units in Q4 2024 at the peak of the supply glut. That number has been steadily declining.

4) Rent Growth Capacity

Austin remains one of the most affordable major apartment markets in the country.

According to JLL, Austin has the lowest rent-to-income ratio among the nation’s 30 largest metros at 16.8%, compared with a national average of 24.7%.

That leaves room for rents to grow while remaining affordable relative to other major markets.

The Glut Is Already Fading

Rents did not fall because people lost jobs or stopped paying.

They fell because a wave of new supply hit the market all at once.

That is the key difference between this cycle and the bottom of the Global Financial Crisis in 2009, and it should shape a very different recovery.

Consider those numbers together. Preliminary Q2 data suggests Austin absorbed roughly 8,000 apartments in a single quarter. For perspective, during the post-pandemic leasing frenzy from 2021 through 2023, Austin averaged roughly 9,500 units of absorption per year. If the preliminary data holds, Austin may have absorbed nearly a full year’s worth of demand in just three months.

At the same time, new apartment deliveries continue to fall, down another 12% from the prior quarter, while Austin’s job growth and economic development story remains as strong as ever.

Absorb the glut. Reduce new supply. Keep the people coming.

That is how a recovery starts.

When Market Conditions Align

At the same time, new apartment deliveries continue to fall, down another 12% from the prior quarter, while Austin’s job growth and economic development story remains as strong as ever.

Absorb the glut. Reduce new supply. Keep the people coming.

That is how a recovery starts.

Put it all together and you get a market condition we do not anticipate twice in a career:

  • A fast-growing city
  • Class A real estate trading at a meaningful discount to replacement cost
  • New supply continuing to decline
  • Exceptionally strong leasing demand
  • Rent affordability that leaves room for future growth

Usually you get one or two of those.

Occasionally, three.

Today, we’re looking at all five.

Want to learn more about our company or schedule a call? Click here to email our investment team.

LinkedIn

Enjoyed the article. Share it.